I’m not a big fan of reality TV, but one show I love and never miss is Project Runway. I get such a kick out of the artistic personalities and seeing real talent ultimately rise to the top. More than anything, though, I’m fascinated by the process of creation. If you haven’t seen Project Runway, it goes something like this: the contestants are given an assignment, such as “make an outfit appropriate for a Times Square billboard out of things you can buy in a pet store.” Then they’re given, perhaps, ten hours to complete the task. Around hour five, Tim Gunn (who is impossible not to adore!) visits the workroom to check out what everyone is doing and offer helpful comments. Then around hour six, they throw a last-minute wrench in the works, such as: “You also need to add an accessory to your outfit and it must be in the color of Heidi Klum’s lipstick,” or something equally ludicrous. (Heidi is a pip. Seriously, how does a woman keep having babies and look like that? It’s utterly beyond me).
So what does this have to do with writing? It occurred to me as I was watching Project Runway the other night that the process of creating an outfit under a tight deadline is very much like writing a book under a tight deadline. There is the “make something from nothing” element, followed by the creation of the design or in the case of a book, the structure. Then there is the execution. Then there is Tim Gunn. When Tim spent time with the designers the other night, critiquing their half-finished projects, one of them said something like “We need you because we’re too close to our work and can’t see the forest for the trees.” Tim is very good at seeing the forest, and that comment reminded me of the reason writers need editors. (Listen up, self-pubbed people! Hire one if you don’t have one).
My editor is really earning her salary as she works with me on The Midwife’s Confession. What draft am I on now? I’ve lost track. Doesn’t matter. This is the one that counts. I’d mentioned that after my editor read my complete manuscript, she wanted me to add the point of view of the late midwife herself. I knew she was right, but that required rewriting the entire book, introducing a storyline that added layers of depth to an already packed tale. I thought I was done then. I knew I’d have some tweaking to do, but I wasn’t quite prepared for my editor’s last-minute suggestion: “Now that the focus is more on the midwife, we no longer need Grace’s (the teenaged girl) point-of-view.” Ack! Once again, I knew she was right. I was so immersed in my creation that, like those Project Runway designers, I hadn’t been able to see the forest for the trees.
So that is my task for this week. It will be the final major overhaul of this book, and it’s about as easy as creating an evening gown out of rawhide chips and dog food bags. See my computer screen above? The full manuscript is on the right, the new mansucript is in the middle. And on the left are the scenes from Grace’s point of view. I am going through them to see what information she gave the reader that the reader simply must know and which I’ll therefore have to seamlessly incorporate into other characters’ points of view. Even more crucial is the need to allow Grace to remain a whole and significant character in the story without allowing her to tell the story herself. Trust me, I have quite a challenge ahead of me!
I’m getting a kick out of it, though. Whenever a book feels like a puzzle to me, it gets my juices flowing. I feel as though Tim Gunn’s paid me a visit, shaken me up a bit, and then told me to “Make it work!” So that’s what I’m up to this week. I want The Midwife’s Confession to knock ’em dead on the runway. You won’t even be able to see where I stitched the dog food bags together.
What an unbelievable challenge Diane!…I know you’re up for the task but this must be taking a real toll on you…I bet your beach condo is looking more and more inviting as we head into September…you will definitely need a relaxing break at Topsail once these rewrites are done!
We’re going Friday, margo, supposedly! I guess the Mideife will be joining me there!
Wow. I’m just glad you agree with the changes. They would be doubly miserable to make if you knew they weren’t going to make the book stronger. Go get ’em, and thanks for this great post.
I am sorry but I would have thrown in the towel by now or have gotten another editor. U r a better woman than I
On another note my bookclub chose your trilogy to read for January yeah. We ate ready a quick novel got November then your trilogy for Jan dnd then delinsky for march
We felt every other month okay
By the way I had tons of food. They loved it
We chose a quick novel for November. Your trilogy for Jan and delinsky fir march
Glad your bookclub had fun, Brenda. The whole trilogy for January? Wow! Let me know if you want me to call by speakerphone.
If a different editor was giving me this feedback, I might just throw in the towel but I trust this editor with my babies!
Emilie, you’re so right.
Brenda, the Trilogy will be great for your bookclub!…wow, all 3 books for January/February…I just might join in and reread them…it will probably be my 10th time reading KEEPER OF THE LIGHT which is fine with me!
Ah Diane, the beach tomorrow!…even tho the Midwife will be joining you and keeping your mind occupied I’m wishing you some rest & relaxation. (-O:
We r reading the first book for January in the trilogy but all agreed they are getting all three to read
Can not read one without the other
Margo-you and I so enjoy the same books-glad you like Sunset Beach-one of my favorites…Don’t forget SOS-it is great. Diane-I think of you so much and what you are going through. When I grade memoirs in one of my classes this week-Honors-they were a little concerned about my suggestions…I used you-a great author as an example-rewrites…you just do it over and over-and you are an expert. That helps. On another note, just finished a first novel-one of the best I have read in a long long long time-set my alarm to get up and finish it…Warning: Rough language…harsh topic…not something for young folks…STILL MISSING by Chevy Stevens…I will read it again…it is amazing…
I’m about to download a new book to read, Brenda, and I’ll try Still Missing. Thanks for the suggestion!
[…] Midwife’s Confession, is a perfect example of how her input improved a story and I’ve sung her praises on this blog […]